Encyclopedia of Wicca & Witchcraft Author: Raven Grimassi Trade
Paperback, 470 pages Publisher: Llewellyn Publication date:
September 2000 ISBN: 1567182577 More Information:
http://www.ecauldron.com/cncbook.php?asin=1567182577
I was excited when I heard about this book. Most encyclopedias
of witchcraft devote the majority of their entries to demons,
medieval witch trials and other things that really have very
little to do with modern Wicca and Witchcraft. Grimassi's
Encyclopedia of Wicca & Witchcraft was billed as being strictly
about Wicca and modern Witchcraft. The proof is in the reading,
of course.
The Encyclopedia of Wicca & Witchcraft is a thick, large book --
larger than the average trade paperback. It's almost the size of
a magazine. The type is a readable size, not the "where did I
leave my magnifying glass" type you'll find in many
encyclopedias. It lives up to its billing: it is just under 500
pages of information on modern Wicca and Witchcraft -- and not
medieval beliefs about pacts with the Christian devil.
There is a lot of information in this book. Unfortunately,
however, the quality of that information is somewhat variable.
The information on individuals was generally written by the
people themselves and is therefore accurate -- if whitewashed in
some cases. A number of important people are not listed at all.
(Perhaps because they did not write entries on themselves?) The
encyclopedia's information on the various Wiccan Traditions was
usually written by members of those traditions. This book
probably has more information on the various Wicca traditions
than any other generally available source.
The other entries in this encyclopedia were all written by Raven
Grimassi. Many of them -- apparently those Grimassi is
personally knowledgeable on -- seem complete and generally
reliable. Entries Grimassi had less personal knowledge of seem
less complete and at times wildly hilarious. This isn't meant as
a jab at Raven. It's obvious he made a tremendous research
effort for this book -- far more than what seems to be done for
most of the Wicca 101 books loading down store shelves.
Unfortunately, he is only one person. He simply cannot know
everything about everything, even when that second "everything"
is limited to Wicca and Witchcraft. This is why most
encyclopedias are compiled from articles by experts on
individual subjects instead of written by a single individual.
In his introduction, Raven acknowledges that he often found a
disconnection in his research between what modern Pagans and
Wiccans believe and teach and what modern scholarship says. He
states that he "decided to simply present both views side by
side." Perhaps he ran up against space limitations, because in
many cases it seems more an encyclopedia of beliefs than and
encyclopedia of scholarly facts. There's nothing wrong with
this, but I think it is something every reader needs to be aware
of.
I think that Grimassi's Encyclopedia of Wicca & Witchcraft is a
good first attempt at a one volume reference work on modern
Wicca and Witchcraft. It's better than any other Witchcraft
encyclopedia I've seen to date. That said, however, its entries
are so variable in completeness and quality, that I can't really
give a general recommendation on this book. If you are an
experienced and knowledgeable Wiccan or Pagan looking for a
handy quick reference (especially on Wiccan traditions) to
consult when you don't have time to dig through your library,
this book is probably a worthwhile purchase -- although it's
certainly not a must have. If, however, you are one of those
people who believe everything you see written without further
research, please avoid this book.
I hope that Llewellyn will publish a second, revised edition of
this encyclopedia in the future. With a bit of work and a few
experts to help Grimassi write articles in areas where he isn't
as knowledgeable, an improved version of this reference could
become a must-have for every Wiccan and Pagan.
This review is one of hundreds of reviews of Pagan, Wiccan,
occult, and metaphysical books in The Cauldron: A Pagan Forum's
Books and Reviews section at
http://www.ecauldron.com/bookstore.php.
About the author:
Randall Sapphire is the founder and co-host of The Cauldron: A Pagan Forum
( http://www.ecauldron.com/ ), a popular Pagan Interfaith web
site and message board. He is also an editor at The Cheap Web
Hosting Report ( http://www.cheapwebhostingreport.com/ ) and
webmaster for a number of other sites.
|
